Tuscan Poached Eggs with Heirloom Tomatoes: the perfect recipe

It’s the perfect recipe to make during a busy garden summer; and it’s easy and fast, fast, fast. Tuscan poached eggs, cooked in an herb-filled sauce made with fresh seasonal heirloom tomatoes: this is it! Whether you’ve grown them the tomatoes and herbs yourself or have brought them home from the farmer’s market, you’re going to want to try making them into this lovely, delicious, quick meal!


Close-up of Tuscan poached eggs in tomato sauce

Tuscan Poached Eggs, the perfect recipe: origin story

Years ago, my daughter-in-law Rachel gave me a cooking magazine that she had brought home from the store where she was working at the time. The manager had to toss out-of-date magazines, and Rachel hated to see them go to waste.

It was high summer, and I was up to my ears in the fruits of my garden, especially heirloom tomatoes, onions, garlic, basil and peppers. The farmer’s markets are bursting with colorful and fresh veggies and fruit that is just picked and dewy fresh, as well. You don’t want to let a single tomato or a stem of basil go to waste.

Then I saw It.

Leafing through the magazine, I spotted a recipe for Tuscan Poached Eggs with heirloom tomatoes that looked interesting, and I fell onto my daily harvest and made it that night for dinner. It was a winner. Not only did it use up many of the goodies from my garden, it also incorporated good eggs from my hens and it made brilliant use of leftover bread from our farmer’s market stand.

And get this: everybody (including our particular little Mack) loved it. #score

Tuscan poached eggs

Tuscan Poached Eggs with heirloom tomatoes: it really was the perfect recipe. Can you fall in love with a recipe? I definitely fell in love with this one that day.

hands full of ripe tomatoes, many colors

And then: disaster.

I lost the magazine. I panicked a bit, at first, when I couldn’t find it and wanted to make the perfect recipe for dinner one night. But then I realized that I probably remembered it in its entirety, anyway, so I sat down, joggled my memory for a minute, and jotted it down. I made it for supper that night, and everybody proclaimed it a wonderful success, as always.

Crisis averted.

toast with Tuscan poached eggs

The Perfect Meal

And now it’s your lucky day . . .

. . . because I’m sharing the perfect recipe with you, and I don’t mind if you share it with your friends, either. Please mention my website (ahem!) when you do!

It’s so good, and so easy, honestly, you’re gonna want to share it! Here ’tis:

Tuscan Poached Eggs with Heirloom Tomatoes: the perfect meal
Author: Amy from vomitingchicken.com
Prep time:
Cook time:
Total time:
Serves: 3-6
This is The Perfect Recipe to make in high summer, when the garden is bursting with fresh heirloom tomatoes, onions, garlic, and basil!
  • 2 Tbs olive oil
  • 2 cloves garlic, squashed and then minced
  • 1/2 cup sweet onion, diced
  • 4 cups diced and cored fresh tomatoes, preferably heirloom (or canned)
  • 1/2 cups fresh basil leaves, sliced
  • kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper, to taste
  • 6 large good eggs
  • 2 Tb chopped fresh chives or parsley for garnish
  • 1/4 cup freshly grated Parmigiano Reggiano
  • thick slices of good crusty bread, drizzled with oil and toasted
  1. First, set a rack in the upper part of your oven and heat the broiler to high.
  2. Meanwhile, on the stovetop, heat an ovenproof skillet over medium heat, add oil and garlic and onion and cook, stirring until it all begins to turn light golden brown, just a minute or two. (Don’t ever burn garlic, by the way, or you’ll want to throw away the pan–phew!).
  3. Add tomatoes and basil and simmer, stirring occasionally, until the sauce thickens, about 8 to 10 minutes. Be sure to breathe in this scent. It’s the scent of high summer, and garden abundance, and joy. Mmmmm. Sweeeet!
  4. Reserve about one-third of the sauce in a bowl and spread the remaining sauce evenly around the skillet. Reduce the heat to medium low, and crack the eggs into the tomato sauce. Lightly spoon the reserved tomato sauce over the whites of the eggs (not the yolks). Cover the pan and cook for about 3 minutes so eggs set slightly. Uncover the skillet and set it under the broiler until the yolks firm up slightly (according to your preferences, natch!) but are still soft.
  5. Remove from oven.
  6. Sprinkle with chives and cheese. Serve immediately with the toasted bread.
  7. I like to dish sauce and one egg per person into small gratin dishes to serve.
  8. By the way, have some extra crusty bread available for juice-sopping purposes!

By the way, if you have no fresh tomatoes available, you can use good canned ones, instead.

heirloom tomatoes with poached eggs

Shop this post

(Affiliate information right here.)

A good cast iron pan

This is my everyday skillet. I will probably use it every day of my life. And, with any hope, beyond!

(Oh, and if you’re not sure how to take care of your cast iron pans. . . check out this post. It’s really soo easy.)

Now I’d better get busy working on dinner . . . it’s high tomato season as I check in here, so you know what I’m gonna make . . . ! 🙂


Pin it for later

Close-up of Tuscan poached eggs in tomato sauceThanks for popping in, gentle reader.

I love ya, I mean it!


19 thoughts on “Tuscan Poached Eggs with Heirloom Tomatoes: the perfect recipe

  1. Dawn @ Guiding Light

    I tried commenting once already – let’s see if it works this time. I love this post…in love with a recipe…that’s not me but I can feel it for you in what you wrote! So glad you got it back and everyone enjoyed it!

  2. Chef William

    a great recipe, much like the Huevos Rancheros that I enjoy so much. Once we get to Mexico and start getting our own eggs from our own free range chickens, I will put your recipe to good use on those days I don’t want jalapenos with breakfast.

  3. Alana (@RamblinGarden)

    I’m sitting in my back yard right now enjoying the 73 degree weather (would you believe??) and the sound of the crickets. With that background – that recipe went right to my printer! Can you hear my stomach growling? I have to modify it a bit for Weight Watchers but – just thinking of good crusty homemade bread with heirloom tomatoes or any kind of garden fresh tomato – groowwlll. In fact I’m looking at my patio tomato plant right now….

  4. Rachel

    This is SUCH a good recipe! Even with store-bought eggs and canned tomatoes (though still vastly inferior to garden tomatoes and eggs from your hens). I’ll have to try it with the improvements you’ve made. –Rachel

    FffffffThthththBbbbbbbb. –Emmett

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      Well, m’dear, I owe it all to YOU. I’ve made it dozens of times and never get tired of it! I’ve made it with home-canned tomatoes and store-bought canned tomatoes, too. 🙂
      *hugs* to you all!

  5. rose/cookinmom

    Wow…I must try this! We make baked eggs but the problem is, (it’s great for winter because we can heat the oven up) come summer, no can do. It’s too hot to turn the oven on at 450 degrees. Making this is better ’cause all ya gotta do is turn the broiler on for a few minutes! Do you use a cast iron skillet? Oh, thank you! We plant about 40 tomato plants in the summer and I can alot as well. However, never done heirloom but sounds like a must!

      1. rose/cookinmom

        Yes, I think it went through for the giveaway. I just loved your new article…going viral, congrats! It didn’t surprise me since you have such a wonderful blog. We grow tomatoes that can the best roma plum, better boy etc. I have lots of basil as well but use it for pestos for the winter soups etc. I make different pesto too, dill, cilantro etc. So so very good! I have a copy of your recipe so will definately try this summer when tomatoes start coming out of my ears! Thanks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.