Inwhich I learn how to make Greek style yogurt

This post contains affiliate links, which might just result in a bit of income for yours truly, which will then result in more blogging activities. Thank you, in advance, for clicking on any links contained in this post!

And no, we don’t have our own milk cow. But, in the funny way that circumstances in life sometimes twist and loop . . . I have a supply of raw milk for the next few weeks, and I’m learning how to make cool things like Greek style yogurt with it! . . . because of (you guessed it) . . . heirloom tomatoes!

Didn’t expect that, didja??

You’ve possibly heard that I planted lots of tomato plants, a whole bunch of them–early–in the hoop house, and (just in case the hoop house ones weren’t happy) another whole bunch in the garden outside, later. I wanted to can lots of tomatoes, to make a goodly supply of salsa and tomato soup and pizza sauce, and I knew that I’d also be able to sell a few of them at farmer’s market. But, Gentle Reader. By all accounts, it’s a wondrous tomato year here in our neck o’the woods. The long, cool, wet spring combined with timely rains this summer and now a bit of heat is just bringing the tomatoes on like crazy!

It’s Crazy Tomato Affluence Time, chickie!

how to make Greek yogurt

And I’m crazy about taking pictures of the “jewels of my garden,” i.e. these gorgeous heirlooms that come in all the pretty colors–yellow and pink and purple and striped and blue and green and yellow striped–and I’ve been posting pictures on Facebook in a very tomato-affluent and braggadocios way (no, no . . . don’t defend me . . . it’s true. I’m proud and it shows. I’ll own it.) and then a friend one day sent me a message, asking, innocently, if I had any tomatoes to spare. My friend Maria. She’s on Facebook. Her tomatoes didn’t do so well this year, sadly. And her family loves tomatoes.

Perhaps they beat her with sticks for running out of tomatoes, like mine did when we ran out of salsa mid-winter last year. 🙁

By the way . . . have you read the poem “Television” by Roald Dahl? It makes me laugh to think of it, and it is where I get the “hitting you with sticks,” er, schtick. Here’s just an excerpt from it:

“So please, oh please, we beg, we pray,
Go throw your TV set away,
And in its place you can install
A lovely bookshelf on the wall.
Then fill the shelves with lots of books,
Ignoring all the dirty looks,
The screams and yells, the bites and kicks,
And children hitting you with sticks-
Fear not, because we promise you
That, in about a week or two
Of having nothing else to do,
They’ll now begin to feel the need
Of having something to read.
And once they start — oh boy, oh boy!
You watch the slowly growing joy
That fills their hearts.” –from “Television” by Roald Dahl

But back to the tomatoes . . . hmmm . . . I had to think for a moment. Any to spare. That was a toughie. . . of course I had some to spare! And then this friend said . . . how much? I would like lots. To can. I’ll pay you for them. And I recoiled. I don’t like taking money from friends. Or family. It’s taken me some time (ask anyone) to not feel guilty about taking it from my market customers, who have become my friends. Awkward. I squirmed. I hedged. I stuttered. I blanched. And then she tipped the scales with her words “I’ve got raw milk and frozen hamburger that I’d trade . . . “

Whoa Nelly. Now that was a fish of another color, entirely. Trading tomatoes to a friend for money makes me uncomfortable. But trading tomatoes to a friend for goodies like raw milk and hamburger feels smart and savvy and symbiotic, and locavorish, if you will. Serendipitous, also. The pressure to use all these glorious tomatoes would be lessened, I knew, if some of them went to my friend’s house, and I would make my friend smile, and I’d get to have raw milk and good grass-fed hamburger for the freezer. Perfect. Definitely a win-win.

So. The deal with set. And I have a few weeks to play with raw milk . . . the first thing I did was to make Greek-style yogurt, from my friend Maria’s easy directions, and it worked like a charm. And it was easy. So easy. And good!

Here’s how I did it (from Maria’s instructions, natch’):

Gather together the following: a half gallon jar of milk (it doesn’t have to be raw), a candy thermometer, a cooler slightly bigger than the jar of milk, 1 Tb yogurt starter or culture, a strainer, a custard cup (you’ll see, be patient!) and a big bowl. And here’s what you do:

Pre-step which you don’t have to do, but we did: take the cream off the top of your raw milk and put it in a special jar for your morning coffee. 🙂 Yum. Smile. Smugly. With anticipation.

how to make Greek yogurt

Now, on to the yogurt-making process:

1. Heat a half gallon of milk to 180° in one pot, while heating water in another pot. I’m assuming you have at least two burners on your stove, right?

2. Once the water boils, pour it into the cooler. Run several inches of cool water into your clean sink. Carefully pour the hot milk, once it reaches temperature, into a clean half gallon mason jar, and move it to your cool-water-filled-sink. I’m assuming you have a jar lifter. If not, buy one, baby! They are essential in any prairie woman’s kitchen! Nothing else will do!

Put the thermometer into the milk, and let the milk sit in the sink (or, if you want to hurry it up a bit–and who wouldn’t–swish it around in the cool water) until the temperature goes down to 110°.

how to make Greek yogurt

3. Pour the hot water out of your cooler, and then carefully lift the jar of cooled milk out of the sink (use your new jar lifter!) and place in cooler*. I put the cooler into the sink, so the warm water that came out ended up in the sink and not the floor or countertop, but you can do what you like. 🙂

how to make Greek yogurt


4. Stir in the culture with a wire whisk. Cover cooler and let sit for 6 hours. Run your errands, gad about, watch a movie, weed your garden, take a nap–whatever you like–knowing that your yogurt is making itself without you.

5. Set up your straining station. Place a custard cup or similar doodad upside down in a big shallow bowl, and put a strainer on top. Maria lent me her cool little cheese strainer, but I think you could use a colander with smallish holes, too. If you don’t have a Maria in your life. But hopefully, you do.

how to make Greek yogurt

If everything has gone well, in 6 hours your milk will be a nice thick yogurt. Now to make it into Greek-style yogurt, you’re going to strain off the whey.

how to make Greek yogurt

6. Pour the yogurt into the strainer. You’ll see the whey begin to separate right away, and seep out of the strainer.

7. Let strain for 30 minutes on countertop, and then move to the ‘fridge to finish draining overnight.

8. Remove your yogurt from the strainer, and put into a suitable lidded container. Or . . . eat it!

9. Reserve whey (I put mine in a mason jar, natch’) in the ‘fridge for more fun raw milk projects (stay tuned . . . ).

I love this yogurt with fruit on top, or just a drizzle of honey . . . . ! Yum!

how to make Greek yogurt

When Bryan and I were still very young and footloose, we spent a bit of time in Greece. We went into a cafe and ordered yogurt, and we were served a large saucer of creamy deliciousness, our first taste of “Greek yogurt” to be sure, made right there in the restaurant, probably, served with a drizzle of honey on top. It was utterly delicious, and a delight to us American students who had only experienced yogurt in its oversweetened state, with a bit of jam to mix in it, in little plastic containers at home. I’ve never forgotten it. This was pretty close to that yogurt.

One, no two–disclaimers. I think I probably overstrained this, my first attempt to make yogurt, and as you can see from the last picture, it’s not as creamy as you might want. I think taking it out of the strainer sooner would have resulted in a creamier yogurt. I’ll do that with the next batch. Also, originally I misunderstood Maria’s instructions* and I left the hot water in the cooler, rather than draining it out, before placing the jar of milk in there to stay warm. So I probably incubated it at a higher temperature than optimal (which is 110°), although it still worked, so no harm, apparently, was done.


By the way . . . I’m having all kids of fun and learning all kinds of new things over at the weekly Barn Hop over at The Prairie Homestead. Join me! ALSO . . . I’m linking up with the fun Home Matters Linky Party right here. Come see!


19 thoughts on “Inwhich I learn how to make Greek style yogurt

  1. Jillian

    Glas it worked for you! To incubate mine I turn on the oven to 200 till good and warm ( or wait till done baking for the day ) I just pop my yogurt and leave in overnight. Turns out great! Can’t wait to see what you do with the whey! I always end up dumping mine. 🙁 Oh and I don’t get raw milk ( I’d love to though ) but I do use non homogenized low temp milk.

  2. Jan K

    Love the use of a cooler to keep the milk warm while it cultures. When it comes time to strain the yogurt, I have found great success using a white (flour sack) cloth to line the inside of my colander and no, it hardly sticks to the cloth at all. After draining mine overnight in the fridge, I add a few tablespoons of cream, sugar and vanilla (to taste) to the yogurt and blend with a blender stick. This really makes it creamy.

    More on these white flour sack towels: I buy these at Walmart where the dish clothes are located 2 pack for $1.98 or 5 pack for $5. I have found so many uses for these. They are great for drying off your hands, and putting a high shine on my stainless appliances and kitchen aid.

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      Jan, thank you so much for these tips! This is one thing I really love about blogging: I learn so much from my readers! I’m going to check out the white flour sack towels at Wal-Mart. I hope ours has them, I know how handy they are! And thanks for the yogurt tips. That was one thing about my first yogurt that I was disappointed by: it wasn’t very creamy. But I’ll try your tips! One question: what’s a “blender stick”?

      1. rita

        People usually mean the hand-held blenders when they say stick blenders. I call it an immersion blender because you don’t have to put whatever you’re blending into the blender container; you put the blender right in the pot. It’s the best thing ever – less dishes, faster results.

        1. rita

          From the google results, ‘stick blender’ is the most popular term, followed by ‘blender stick’, and trailing behind is ‘immersion blender’. You win! 🙂 Mine is a KitchenAid too and I’m very pleased with it. I think we got ours on sale at a store for $45 and we’ve bought our girls these too. One of the girls’ roommates burned out 2 of them making hummus that was too dry. If what you’re making is on the dry side, pulsing it may be the best plan. Soups and such, let’er rip! We’ve had ours for a lot of years without any trouble. And if it died, I’d run out and get another one asap, they’re that handy! I agree with you!

          1. dramamamafive Post author

            Thanks Rita! I do have an immersion blender, but I don’t use it that often–I’m going to give it more chances to be used though. I mostly use it when I make cream soups or such, and I’ve got to start making tomato soup for the pantry. Thanks for all the ideas!

        2. dramamamafive Post author

          Oh, okay! Thanks Jan! And I’ll let you know about the flour sack towels. I think I’ve seen them at our farm store. But I’ll check Wal-Mart, I’ll bet they’d be a better price there.

  3. Angela Dawn

    I’d love to see a post on some of your tomato recipes. I have had an over-abundance of tomatoes other years (not this year, sadly), and felt quite at a lose to know how to process them. Especially for any end products that should be thick, like pizza sauce.

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      Angela, I’m working on it! Look for posts in the next couple of weeks with my salsa recipe, and my tomato soup recipe, and for pizza sauce, too. As long as the tomatoes keep producing, I’ll be writing about them.

  4. Shirley Wood

    Very impressive to swap tomatoes for milk and beef! I wish I lived closer, I’d clean your house for some of those beautiful tomatoes! I need to do a better job. My tomatoes were terrible this year. I wouldn’t really even call them tomatoes and I started them from seed indoors, loved on them and all that good stuff! Maybe next year! So glad you shared with us at The Home Matters Linky Party! Please be sure to come back this Wednesday and share again!

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      THAT’s a great idea! . . . maybe I could throw in a tank of gas to get you here . . . where do you live?? I still have PLENTY of tomatoes, and my house still needs a good cleaning, too. 🙁

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.