National Pie Day: Cranberry Pie and an NFL player in my living room

Oh, I love National Pie Day, don’t you? Wait! Don’t tell me that you didn’t know that National Pie Day is held on January 23 every year? That it’s this Friday, as a matter of fact. I’m sharing my favorite pie recipe (currently!) a bit early, so if you’d like to make pie to share on National Pie Day–this Friday, in fact–you’ll be prepared with this fabulous new recipe.

Also I’m going to tell you about having a NFL football player in my living room this weekend, eating (you guessed it!) pie.

Which to share first? Okay, okay–football player first, and then pie.

My daughter Bethie is engaged to a sweet fella from Hawaii, who has a rather large family back home. His brother John came to visit him for a couple of weeks, and we had the privilege of spending most of Sunday with these three. John is a linebacker for the Jacksonville Jaguars. You know that I’m not much of a football fan. Well, after meeting John, I might just have to become one. At least I will be following the Jaguars, since John is my new BFF.

I am going to soon be related to this fella.

I am going to soon be related to this fella: John Lotulelei, linebacker for the Jacksonville Jaguars.

We made homemade ramen for dinner (not the packeted kind, and I will be sharing this recipe with you  next week, because it was fabulous! and not difficult at all to make, and it gave Amalia and me the excuse to investigate an Asian market in the city, and to buy some cunning new bowls–but more about that later) and it was a hit. (And some Asian soup spoons.)

My mom dropped in on us during a gerbil emergency (don’t ask) the night before, and after it was resolved, she asked me what I was going to do that evening. “Make pie for tomorrow,” said I. I believe my shoulders probably shlumped just the merest bit. Unintentionally, you understand. It had been a busy day. I had the scoop shovel out, you know, cleaning house, and also I was making broth and tripping over our little cat that is suddenly in heat and quite irritatingly obvious about it, 🙁 and then there was the aforementioned gerbil emergency to deal with. Yikes.

This is the pie that I was wanting to make: Crumbled Pecan Cranberry Pie.

This is the pie that I was wanting to make: Crumbled Pecan Cranberry Pie.

“Oh Amy,” she said, pity in her eyes, (or was that quiet sorrow over her daught’s ineptitude?) “Why tonight?” she asked. I explained that we would be at church in the morning, and that the pies were for after-lunch dessert, and the, you know, gerbil emergency took more time than I reckoned . . . well, actually I didn’t reckon on the gerbil emergency at all . . .

Side, mother-related note: This is why I love my mother: well, one of the many, many reasons I love my mother. . . I’m sure that when Mom glanced about, she could spot that the house wasn’t ready for company yet (it never is, *heavy, heavy sigh*). It was past suppertime, but I hadn’t started thinking about supper yet, either. It was around 6:30 when she asked me what my evening plans were, and her eyebrows lifted just the slightest bit, as if the thought of making pie in the evening is not something that she has ever contemplated.

Although I know, from experience, that it is. “Sure,” I said, “I want pie to serve tomorrow after lunch, so I’m going to make a couple of pies. After I make supper, of course!” 🙂 I tried to appear cheerful and capable, although actually I was bone-tired and wanting nothing more than to sit down and watch Gilligan’s Island (yep, that tired) with little Mack. Mom paused, no doubt imagining me still up at midnight, weeping over a pie crust that is not perfect and cursing my dumb luck and my sorry lack of pie-making gifts. “I’ll make you a couple of pies,” she said, with a barely discernible sigh. “Apple or rhubarb?”

There’s another reason I love my mother. Also. Her pies (that she is so generous with) are, like, a million times better than mine. Mine are good. Hers are . . . . perfect. Or practically so.

So, quite Mom-like, Mom made three pies: banana cream (with meringue on top), apple, and rhubarb, and she brought them over the next afternoon. She brought Dad, too, since Dad actually does follow football, and he wanted to meet the NFL football player who was sitting in my living room. (Also she needed help carrying all those pies.) (Just joking, Dad!)

And that’s also why I’m not jealous (not a bit) that Mom got her picture taken with John and I didn’t.

Not bitter. Not a bit of it, ya’all.


Who knew that a professional football player could be so absolutely fun to be with, though I shouldn’t have been surprised, since I’m crazy about his brother, my soon-to-be son-in-law Saia, the love of my daught Bethie’s life. I kept asking John if he didn’t want to go outside and toss the pigskin around, and he just laughed. He taught little Mack some pretty fancy marble-playing skills (watch out!) and he and Saia told story after story of their growing-up years. It was pretty awesome.

But back to pie. Now that I’ve told you that Mom’s pies are better than mine (but you already knew that, right?) my credibility as a pie maker might be just slightly tarnished, but oh well. 🙂 If you love a pie with a bit of tartness: think sour cherry, or rhubarb, or gooseberry, you’ll love this cranberry pie with pecan crumble topping. I started with a recipe from smitten kitchen, and then I tweaked it a bit. You know. We pie makers do like to tweak our recipes, that is, when we’re not hanging out with NFL football players and watching them eat our pie, right, Mom?


I made this pie for Thanksgiving, as a matter of fact, and there were so many pies that day that my pie didn’t get eaten, not entirely, at least. I didn’t mind this in the least, in fact I was secretly delighted. There were several pieces left, which I surreptitiously covered and scooted to a very private place indeed, and they made splendid breakfast fare for days afterwards. 🙂 With a bit of whipped cream or ice cream balanced sweetly on the side. Yummm. . . .

Mom tweaks, too. All the time. Oftentimes she tweaks pie recipes late into the night. Dad can attest to this.

Pecan Crumbled Cranberry Pie
Author: Amy from
Prep time:
Cook time:
Total time:
Serves: 1 pie
I adapted a recipe from Smitten Kitchen to make this pie. It is currently MY VERY FAVORITE pie recipe, and that says a lot!
  • 4 1/2 cups fresh or frozen cranberries (from 1 1/2 12-ounce bags)
  • 1 cup granulated sugar, plus 1 to 2 more tablespoons, if desired, to taste
  • A few gratings of orange zest
  • A few gratings of fresh ginger (yes!)
  • A pinch of salt
  • 1 tablespoon cornstarch
  • Streusel
  • 2/3 cup rolled oats
  • 1/2 cup all-purpose flour
  • 1/3 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/3 cup light or dark brown sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground ginger
  • 1/4 teaspoon sea salt
  • 3/4 cup pecans, toasted if you have the time (make the time, Gentle Reader, make the time)
  • 6 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted and cooled
  1. Preheat oven to 375.
  2. Roll out your favorite pastry into a pie plate and poke several times with a fork. Crimp edges.
  3. Make the filling: Combine all filling ingredients (no need to defrost frozen cranberries) in a saucepan over medium heat. After about 5 minutes, berries will begin to leak juices.
  4. Cook, stirring for 5 minutes more until filling is loose.
  5. If desired, you can lightly crush the mixture once or twice with a potato masher, but try to leave most berries intact.
  6. Transfer filling to a bowl to let it cool for 5 to 10 minutes while you make the crumble topping.
  7. Make the topping: If using whole oats, grind them in a blender or food processor.
  8. Add pecans and coarsely grind them too.
  9. Add remaining ingredients except the butter, pulsing a few times to combine.
  10. Add butter, pulsing until crumbles form. Sprinkle topping over cranberry filling.
  11. Bake pie for 45 to 50 minutes, until juices are bubbling enough that they splash a bit onto the crumb topping. If pie browns too quickly, cover top with a piece of foil for remaining baking time.
  12. Transfer to a wire rack to cool a bit before serving showered with powdered sugar and alongside whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.


By the way, if you don’t have a favorite pie pastry recipe, you can use mine, which is here.

Here are oodles of ideas of other ways to celebrate National Pie Day (hint: they all involve pie), just in case you’re at a loss, which I very much doubt.

16 thoughts on “National Pie Day: Cranberry Pie and an NFL player in my living room

  1. Jillian

    Thank you for the reminder! I’m planning on making a cranberry/apple pie. I’m in Washington gotta use apples since they are coming out my ears! Can you believe granny smith are 39 cents a pound at my local farm stand?? At one point honey crisps were 79. Yumm!

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      No, no, no, I’m not listennnnning!!! Jillian, if apples were 39 cents here, I’d be eating nothing but apples. Apple pie, apple cobbler, apple sauce, apple slices. . . . what’s for dinner, Mom? APPLES!! I think honey crisps here are over $2.00 per lb, can you believe it? I’m hoping with the gas prices going down that eventually we’ll have lower grocery prices? *crossing fingers*

  2. Francene Stanley

    Oh, Amy. You keep us entertained with your inadequacies, all the while sniggering in your perfect home. It must be. Everyone, just everyone, turns up for a piece of your (mother’s) pie. The president will probably call in next week.

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      Gosh, Francene, if that’s true, I’m gonna have to get out the REALLY BIG scoop shovel to clean house before then. . . . !!! I did hear today that the President is making surprise appearances in red states (Republican) to get publicity, so . . . you never know!

  3. Chef William Chaney

    That’s great, a day to eat pie. I think I will start with a breakfast pie filled with sausage, eggs and lots of vegetables..dinner can be a chicken pot pie, and for a dessert latter in the day I will have a nice apple pie with butter pecan ice cream…I don’t have any football players to hang out with, after their poor performance this past weekend, all the football players here in Wisconsin have gone into hiding. However, I do like the idea of pie and ice cream for breakfast. You need a scoop shovel to clean your house, my-o-my that is an interesting tidbit. I don’t have anyone to make a pie or three for me and I won’t eat a store bought pie without going to a special shop. That shop now gets $12.00 per pie so you can guess who is going to make his own pies this week………….

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      You crack me up. Are you sure you’re going to be able to fit into your moving van, once you’ve eaten ALL THAT PIE??

  4. Shellye L Lyons

    OMG, I’m excited about pie day and the fact that you know an NFL player. On pie, I’m going to try your recipe. It looks great! I think I’ll make my mom’s famous banana surprise cheesecake tomorrow though. I’ll have to repost the recipe. On the NFL player, congrats! We have something in common, sort of. Because my hubby is a sports fanatic and has his own sports publication, he talks to NFL, NBA, and other players a lot. Most recently, I’ve had the opportunity to meet Marcus Spears, Dante Wesley, Miles Austin, and others. He’s also into entertainment so I’ve met some celebrities as well. No one has come into the family though! Thanks for the uplifting post. I smiled the whole time I read it!

    1. dramamamafive Post author

      Shellye, Wow, I’m impressed! John is my Famous Person of the Year. If I met another famous person this year, it would be over my limit. But you just mentioned several, and the year is just getting started. Very cool!!

  5. Angie Scheie

    I know I should be raving about the pie since it looks sweet and delicious, but I’m actually more excited for your new family edition! I heard John on a sports radio interview when he was here with the Hawks. I was SO hoping he would stay because he sounded like such a great guy. He gets to play with some amazing defensive players and coach in Jacksonville, so their gain is our loss :(. Congrats to your daughter and I hope you will be cheering loud and proud for him!!

  6. Joyce Rivera

    Oh, Amy, your blogs are always entertaining! There must never be a dull moment in the Miller household–or a no-delicious-food-of-some-kind moment either! And I’m sure you stay calm, cool, and collected throught it all! 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.